Barrettes vs Snap Clips vs Claw Clips: Which Clip for What
Share
"Hair clip" covers at least five different mechanisms, and each one is good at a different job. A claw clip that is perfect for a twist is useless for bangs; a snap clip that holds bangs neatly will not hold a ponytail. Here is what each type is for, using pieces from our barrettes and hair clips.
The short answer
| Type | How it closes | Holds | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Claw clip | Spring-loaded jaws with teeth | From a section to all your hair | Twists, updos, half-up |
| French barrette | Hinged clasp closes over a curved bar | A medium section, flat | Half-up, low ponytail cover |
| Snap clip | A flexible metal tab that clicks shut | A small section | Bangs, flyaways, fine hair |
| Side clip (duck-bill / alligator) | Long jaws on a spring | A section at the side | Side-swept looks, short hair |
| Hair pin / stick | No closing — woven through | A bun or twist | Buns, French twists |
Claw clips
The only clip that can hold all of your hair at once. Size decides how much: large for a full twist, small for a section. See which claw clip for thick or fine hair.
Barrettes
A barrette closes flat against the head, which makes it the neatest option for a half-up or for covering a ponytail elastic. The French barrette, with a hinged clasp, holds more hair than a spring barrette.
Snap clips
Light and flat, they disappear into the hair and are the best clip for fine hair and bangs. They hold only a small section — use two or three rather than one big one.
Side clips
Long duck-bill or alligator jaws on a spring, for sweeping one side back. They suit short hair and bobs, where a back section is too short to gather. See our side hair clips.
Pins and sticks
For buns and twists, a pin woven through the hair holds better than any clip and weighs less. See how to use hair pins.
Which clip for your hair type
| Hair | First choice | Also good | Skip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fine or thin | Snap clips, small claw | Slim French barrette | Large, heavy claws |
| Medium | Medium claw, French barrette | Side clips | Snap clips for a whole half-up |
| Thick | Large claw, Hold 3 | Hair fork | Snap clips for anything but bangs |
| Short or bob | Snap clips, mini claw, side clip | Thin headband | Large claws, hair sticks |
| Curly | Claw clip | Hair fork | Barrettes that press curls flat |
How to put each one in
- Claw clip: twist the hair first, then close the clip across the twist with the teeth facing your head.
- French barrette: smooth the section, slide the bar under it from one side and close the clasp over the top. The slim acetate French barrette is Hold 2.
- Snap clip: open it, slide it in flat against your head in the direction the hair falls, and press the centre until it clicks. Try the polka dot bow snap clip.
- Side clip: sweep the section back, slide the open jaws in from behind, pointing toward your face, and let it close.
- Pin or stick: make the bun or twist first, push the pin in, turn it, and push it home. See how to use a hair stick.
If you buy two
A medium claw clip and a pair of snap clips cover almost every day: the claw for twists and half-up, the snaps for bangs and stray pieces.
Common mistakes
- A snap clip doing a barrette's job. Snap clips are made for a small section. Across a whole half-up they pop open.
- A barrette over too much hair. If the clasp only just closes, the barrette strains and slides. Take a smaller section or switch to a claw.
- A claw on untwisted hair. A claw holds a twist, not a loose curtain of hair. Twist first.
- One big clip where two small ones would do. On fine or short hair, two snap clips side by side grip better than one larger clip.
For ten ways to wear these clips in a half-up, see half-up, half-down hairstyles.
Quick answers
Claw clip or hair claw?
The same thing — "hair claw", "claw clip" and "jaw clip" all mean the spring-loaded clip with teeth.
Hair clip or hair pin?
A clip closes on the hair; a pin is pushed or woven through it.
Are barrettes in style?
Yes — especially French barrettes and bow barrettes, at any age.


